Are You My First? Hulu Cast
Yes, the show “Are You My First?” on Hulu delivers a refreshingly honest and slightly chaotic batch of 21 singles all open about being virgins, all hoping paradise leads to something, well, memorable. Instead of puffy bios and formulaic blurbs, let’s just meet them as the messy, hopeful, super-real humans they are. Each has a story, some funny, some fierce, some surprisingly sweet. Here they are, each in their moment:
Andrew (25):
Tech sales guy from Salt Lake City. Still holding out for “the one,” as if he’s got her resume in a manila folder somewhere. The kind of earnest that makes you root for him.
Brooklyn (24):
Los Angeles dancer, model, and instructor. Says love is “worth the wait,” which tells you she’s danced around a lot—just not that.
Carissa (27):
Long Beach photographer, social media manager. Waiting for the one who truly fits, like that one camera lens you only use for special gigs.
Deya (28):
Miami/Fort Lauderdale small business owner. Wants a storybook romance because, honestly, who doesn’t want a happy ending?
Farha (25):
Writer and content creator from Miami. Grew up religious but approaches love with thoughtful slowness—and 1.7million TikTok followers.
Godwin (27):
Real estate developer from New Jersey, also a model and actor. Once walked for Rihanna. Looking for a queen, not a fling.
Hakeem (27):
Voiceover artist and poet, Atlanta-based. Approaches intimacy cautiously—he knows the risks, and probably has a poem about it.
Jade (28):
Miss New Orleans USA, NFL cheerleader, marketing specialist. Never had a serious relationship, but brings parade energy everywhere.
Jake (32):
Los Angeles caregiver. Saving himself for marriage. Faith runs deep—maybe deeper than the LA pool scene. You can sense the stoicism.
Katya (28):
Theatre artist divides life between Orange County and New York. For Katya, “sex is about power,” so every conversation is a chess game.
Krash (24):
Miami-based social media manager. Had a strict upbringing and the discipline shows: he could probably resist even the best Instagram thirst trap.
Layne (24):
Oklahoma pilot with zero “serious girlfriend” experience. This might just become his top takeoff story.
Madi (28):
Marketing manager (Austin). Fears intimacy, waits for true love, and probably watches more rom-coms than is healthy.
Michael (26):
Austin tour guide & comic, Netflix’s “Twentysomethings: Austin.” Needs to “work through intimacy fears”—at least he’ll make everyone laugh getting there.
Mike (34):
A gym owner from San Diego, famous as the Bachelorette’s resident virgin. He’s waited this long—he’s not blinking now.
Noah (25):
San Clemente business owner. Wants to wait until marriage—and agreed to join a reality show because, sure, why not shake things up.
Rachael (30):
Tampa cocktail waitress and romance author (is that like fantasy but with more candles?). Previously had a health issue delaying intimacy.
Sara (28):
San Diego student. Studies came first, but now she’s “holding out for love.” Maybe she’s the romantic heart of the villa.
Spencer (25):
Solar salesman from Vancouver Island/Idaho. Looking for meaning, so expect a little soul searching (or at least a slow dance).
Ty (25):
Mormon, web developer from Provo, BYU grad. Still waiting (not pressed), probably with a spreadsheet for dating odds.
Vivek (23):
Indian-origin accountant and model in LA. Wants the first time to be “with someone he truly trusts.” Sincere and quietly searching.
Are You My First? Hulu Hosts
Colton Underwood and Kaitlyn Bristowe are your guides as hosts. Colton’s famously “the virgin Bachelor,” and Kaitlyn is joy in a bottle—you might remember her as The Bachelorette (or just from podcasts and dance shows). It’s a surprisingly down-to-earth combo, and their gentle, slightly teasing vibes make the show feel less like science experiment, more like summer camp for late bloomers. Fun, right?
Are You My First? Hulu Release Date
Straight up: The whole first season premiered August 18, 2025, on Hulu (and Disney+ if you’re not in the U.S.). All ten episodes dropped the same day—which is perfect for anyone who likes to binge and cringe in equal measure, or process reality TV like it’s a group project, snacks included.
areyoumyfirst on Instagram, A new reality series, Are You My First, is set to premiere on August 18, bringing together 21 virgins on one beach for a unique experience.
https://www.instagram.com/p/DM8T4S6vxKi/
https://www.instagram.com/p/DNgrFXLybTf/
