Will There Be a Season 2 of Overcompensating?
Big news: Overcompensating is absolutely coming back for a second season, and honestly, it’s about time. The show’s official renewal hit on September 10, and the reaction online felt like a collective sigh of relief—kind of like when you realize your favorite bodega is still open after a thunderstorm. Fans (myself included) have been itching for closure after that brutal cliffhanger last season—the kind of ending that makes you mutter “don’t do me like that” at your TV. Seriously, did Benny just get outed in front of everyone? My group chat was chaos.
So, yeah, Season 2 is happening—Prime Video confirmed it, Benito Skinner celebrated it, and the whole cast is headed back to Yates University. I think what makes this show stand out is how it balances razor-sharp college satire with those weird, cringey moments most of us recognize from our own pasts, only much, much funnier. Benito’s Benny is a closeted ex-football star—you know, Idaho golden boy with more secrets than a Netflix password—trying to fit in with new misfit friends, fake IDs, and a vibe that’s equal parts messy and heartfelt.
https://www.instagram.com/p/DObeIdTCW8s/
People are wondering where the story’s headed, and so am I. The good news is, all signs point to the original crew returning: Wally Baram as Carmen, Beth Barone, Adam DiMarco, and more—plus some wild guest stars (Charli XCX cameo last season? Unreal.). No spoilers yet on plot, but I need to know what happens after that argument that shook up Benny’s world. The last time a new season announcement felt this satisfying was probably when The Bear got renewed and my cousin texted me at 6AM in all caps. Relatable excitement.
'If you haven’t watched Overcompensating yet, now’s a good time to catch up before Season 2 lands—especially if you’re into college comedies that get weird and emotional at the same time, or if you’ve ever felt like the odd one out at a frat party (same). This one feels like more than just another streaming sitcom—it’s got just enough heart (and cringe) to keep it real, and now that Season 2’s on the way, the wait for answers is officially over.
