Who Went Home on ‘The Golden Bachelor’ Tonight?
It’s that bittersweet point in the season again when the fairytale starts to feel a little too real. On tonight’s Golden Bachelor episode (October 15, 2025), Mel Owens made the toughest cuts yet, saying goodbye to three women before hometown dates. Carol, Cheryl, and Nicolle, all fan favorites in their own way, packed their bags, each leaving behind a little bit of sparkle and chaos for good measure.
Carol Says Goodbye on Her Own Terms
Carol didn’t wait for a rose ceremony. She walked herself out, and honestly, I respected that. After weeks without a one-on-one date, she finally admitted what many of us had whispered to our TVs: “It’s just not happening.” She wanted a real connection, not polite nods and group-date small talk at Butterfly Mountain. Maybe it was the moment with the shaman that cleared her head, or maybe it was just intuition. Either way, her exit felt graceful, the kind that makes you root for her to show up next season as the Golden Bachelorette.
Nicolle’s Glitter Fades
Ah, Nicolle. The Instagram-loving spirit of the house, who came in swinging with high heels and hashtags. Mel finally saw through the charm this week. When she started talking about “monetizing her plant-based cookbook” during a heart-to-heart, his face said it all. This wasn’t love, it was branding. Their goodbye was civil, but you could tell he was done with the drama. I half expected her to plug her new podcast on the way out.
Cheryl’s Quiet Exit
And then there was Cheryl, kind, warm, and consistently overlooked. She gave Mel compassion when others gave critique, but it wasn’t enough. Watching her walk out with that soft, hopeful smile broke my heart a little. In the limo, she wished him well. Classic Cheryl classy until the end.
https://www.instagram.com/p/DP2gm7Vjiii/
Who’s Still in the Game?
Three women remain standing: Cindy, Peg, and Debbie. Cindy got the starry one-on-one date (he literally named a star after her extra, but kind of adorable). Peg and Debbie each bring something strong to the table humor, loyalty, maybe a bit of unicycle-riding bravery in Peg’s case.
Next week? Hometown visits. And probably a few more tears. Grab your tissues and your tea things are about to get real.
Disclaimer: Episode outcomes are based on the official October 15, 2025 broadcast. Viewer experiences may vary depending on regional streaming schedules.
